Agreed value car insurance: what it pays, and why stated value is not the same

Agreed value means you and the insurer settle what the car is worth when the policy is written, and that is the amount paid if the car is stolen or totaled in a covered loss, less any deductible. An ordinary auto policy does not work that way. It pays actual cash value, which the Texas Department of Insurance defines as “the cost to replace your car, minus depreciation.” A third label, stated value, sounds like agreed value and is not: the insurer keeps the right to pay the lower depreciated figure.

For a car that holds or gains value, the difference is the whole point of the policy. Below: how each kind pays, how an agreed value gets set, what the policies ask of you in return, and the questions to put to an insurer before you sign.

Agreed, stated and actual cash value, side by side

• Agreed value. Set in advance. On a covered total loss the insurer pays that amount, minus the deductible. Hagerty calls its version Guaranteed Value and says it includes sales tax and fees unless state law prohibits it.
• Stated value (also “stated amount”). You name a figure, but Hagerty says the insurer can pay “either your vehicle’s depreciated cash value amount or the cost to replace your vehicle” and will choose the lower. Progressive says the same: the stated value or the actual cash value, whichever is lower.
• Actual cash value. The standard auto policy. Replacement cost minus depreciation for wear, tear and age, worked out at the time of the loss.

Grundy Insurance, which says its founder began selling agreed value collector policies in 1947, puts the stated value problem bluntly: a stated value policy “is nothing more than an Actual Cash Value policy with an upward limit on how much an insurance company will pay.” It depreciates on the way down and caps you on the way up.

How the value gets agreed

You propose a figure and the insurer checks it. Grundy describes the process: the application states the value you want, underwriters look at photos and any supporting documents, and the figure is compared with the agency’s guidelines for similar cars in similar condition. It may ask for restoration receipts or more photos, and it says underwriters will tell you if the number is too low or too high. Grundy says 95% of requested values are approved and bound on the day the application arrives.

Values move, so the policy should move with them. Grundy says the insured value can be adjusted annually, and at any time by agreement. Hagerty sells an option it calls “Vehicle Under Construction” for cars mid-restoration that raises the Guaranteed Value by 10% a quarter, up to $25,000 in total, with $750 of cover for tools.

If you bought the car at auction, the invoice is your best evidence of value. Keep it with the photos. How to buy a car at Barrett-Jackson or Mecum covers what the buyer’s premium adds to that invoice.

What the policy asks of you

Collector policies are priced for cars that are driven less and stored well, and the eligibility rules say so. American Collectors Insurance lists what it expects:

• The car is in restored or good condition
• It is stored in an enclosed, secure building when not in use
• The driver has a clean record, at least five years of licensed driving, and a personal auto policy on an everyday car
• Use is limited to hobby events, occasional pleasure driving and infrequent other use
• No commuting, no use as a backup to your regular car, no business use, no off-road driving and no racing

Mileage counts too. Hagerty says 3,500 miles a year or fewer is typical for a collectible car, that up to 7,500 may be considered, and that “the main requirement is that your classic isn’t used as a daily driver.”

Age is less strict than most people assume. American Collectors says the common threshold is around 20 to 25 years, varying by insurer, and warns against assuming any old car automatically qualifies. Hagerty’s own definition of a collector car runs from the earliest cars to “newer limited edition, exotic autos,” so a modern exotic can qualify on the same usage rules.

Track days are a separate policy

American Collectors says no coverage is provided for on-track damage or accidents. A collector car that also does HPDE or competition events “may be eligible for off-track car insurance coverage for physical damage only.” If the car goes on track, that needs its own single-event policy, covered in Does your car insurance cover a track day?.

When the car is a total loss

Grundy says a car may be declared a total loss when the damage is irreparable or the repair cost exceeds a set share of the insured value, typically 80%. A car that is totaled and bought back may need a salvage title, depending on the state, which hurts its value when you sell. Grundy says it can usually settle such a claim as a partial loss instead, by deducting the buyback price from the repair cost, where state rules allow.

Hagerty’s answer is a coverage called Cherished Salvage, which lets you keep the car and still receive the full Guaranteed Value after a covered total loss. Its own footnote says any deductible, and the salvage value when you keep the car, is subtracted from the payment. Another footnote on the same page says some coverage is not available in New York, so New York owners should ask which.

Two coverages owners get wrong

Collision, not just comprehensive. Comprehensive covers loss other than a collision: Grundy’s list includes fire, theft, falling objects, hail, flood, vandalism and contact with an animal. Collision covers the car hitting or being hit by something, and Grundy’s examples include another car rolling into yours at a show and backing into a closed garage door. Grundy also tells of a collector whose policy turned out to be comprehensive only when two of his cars broke loose and struck each other inside a trailer: the damage was not covered.

Uninsured motorist limits follow you, not the car. Grundy points out that “who is insured” is defined by people, so the uninsured and underinsured motorist limits on your everyday policy carry over when you drive the collector car, and the other way round. Set them on both policies with that in mind.

Questions to ask before you buy a policy

• On a covered total loss, do you pay the full insured amount, or the lesser of that amount and actual cash value?
• Does the payment include sales tax and fees?
• What deductible applies, and is there a separate one for partial losses?
• What are the mileage and storage conditions, and what happens if I exceed them?
• Can I raise the value mid-term, and what do you need to see?
• If the car is totaled, can I keep it, and how is the payment reduced if I do?
• Does the policy cover the car in a trailer, at a show and at a shop?

How the premium on an everyday policy is set, and why the quote should come before the test drive, is in Insurance is the second payment.

Questions people ask

What is agreed value car insurance?

Cover where the car’s value is fixed when the policy starts, and that amount is paid on a covered total loss, minus the deductible. Grundy, which sells only agreed value policies, says many collector insurers have followed its lead.

Is stated value the same as agreed value?

No. Under a stated value policy the insurer can pay the lower of the stated figure and the car’s actual cash value, according to both Hagerty and Progressive. Agreed value pays the agreed amount.

Does agreed value pay out on a partial loss?

Progressive says the insurer pays up to the agreed amount for repairs. The agreed figure is the ceiling for a repair claim; the repair cost decides what is actually paid.

Can I use an agreed value policy on a car I drive every day?

Usually not. American Collectors excludes commuting and backup use, and Hagerty says the car must not be a daily driver.

Do I need a garage?

American Collectors requires the car to be stored securely in an enclosed facility when not in use. Ask each insurer what it accepts, such as a storage unit or a shared garage.

What does a stored car need for cover over the winter?

Do not cancel a policy on a registered car without checking your state’s plate rules first. Storing a car for winter covers New York, Pennsylvania and Michigan. In Virginia, antique plates still require liability insurance; see antique and historic plates.

No premiums are quoted here, because none of these insurers publishes a price without a quote. This is not insurance advice; terms differ by insurer and by state, and the wording above was read on each company’s or agency’s own page on 12 November 2026.

InsuranceCollector carsOwnership

Mario Bailey

Founder, Driven Life

Mario Bailey founded Driven Life, which is published by Revlent LLC. He is a U.S. Air Force veteran and a tech founder, and has worked as a software engineer for more than ten years. He edits the site and is responsible for every page on it: the meet, club and rally guides, the metro and state hubs, the car and tool pages, and the magazine.